Chapter One: Can we cover it all?

Can we cover it all? This discussion will not be encyclopedic. We cannot cover all the issues and side bars in the Charismatic Movement (CM)and the controversies which often surround it. The CM is too diverse. We can discuss common, key issues. We must limit our discussion after all; otherwise, we will mire ourselves in too many rabbit trails. Thus, the discussion will be limited in scope and our discussion will not be comprehensive. Hopefully, our discussion will not be combative or ungracious. We intend to cover roughly eleven (11) topics, or chapters. They are as follows.

Scripture. The basis of the Christian faith is Scripture by which we renew our minds. It is through the Scriptures that we understand the mind of God. They are inspired by God, breathed out by Him, and profitable for teaching, reproof, correction, and instruction in all matters of righteousness, including Charismatic issues. Scripture is the will of God in written form. Thus, chapter two deals with the CM and Scripture. One's approach to Scripture is vital to the discussion.

Tongues. "Speaking in tongues" is one of the more common manifestations or trademarks of the CM. Consequently, chapter three will focus on "tongues."

Healing. Healing is another hallmark of the CM. Healing services and allegations of miraculous healing are prominent in many churches and television ministries in the CM. Thus, chapter four discusses healing and the CM.

Signs and Wonders. Any discussion of healing leads to discussing "signs and wonders (i.e. miracles)." Chapter five asks and answers the question, "Just what are signs and wonders (miracles) and their purpose?" This will center on an analysis of the historical, inerrant, and infallible record of miracles in Scripture. We will compare and contrast "today's miracles" with those of the biblical record.

"Greater Works Than These." Chapter six asks and answers the question "What are the greater works to which Christ referred in John 14?" Many point to the "greater works" Christ spoke of as a warrant for much of what goes on in the CM today. Are they?

"Modern" Prophets. Chapter seven addresses the matter of "modern prophecy." Many claim to be prophets today in the CM. Should they make such claims? Are such claims legitimate? What if they prophesy inaccurately? What does the Bible say about prophecies which do not come true? Chapter six addresses these questions.

Cessation or Continuation. Chapter eight addresses the potential for the cessation and fade of the sign gifts. Have the sign gifts ceased? Will they cease? Are these supernatural gifts for today? What does the Bible say? Chapter seven addresses these questions.

Scripture's Authority. There are practices present in the CM which clearly contradict Scripture. How can such practices receive the blessing of God? Are these practices legitimate? Does God contradict Himself or violate His own integrity? Chapter nine wrestles with this question.

Too willing, yet unwilling? Chapter ten concerns itself with the matter of discernment. Are some simply too willing to believe any claim or anyone? What does the Bible say about discernment?

Biblical or Unbiblical? Chapter eleven wraps up the discussion of the CM by asking for answers to questions which cannot go unanswered. Can Christians wink at unbiblical practices within a movement and be "right with God?" Can our CM brothers afford to ignore glaring issues within the movement? What does the Bible say?

Our discussion will be limited to these eleven (11) topics because we cannot "cover it all." Nevertheless, what we will discuss should be sufficient to provoke thought and encourage reflection and consideration. Ideologues in the CM will not be persuaded. However, we do not direct this discussion to ideologues.

We must not see this discussion as a war against a movement (or each other) but an appeal to Christian brothers and sisters over substantive matters which concern the church of the Living God. Therefore, let us address these matters as brothers and sisters in Christ rather than opponents as we pray for clarity, integrity, and mutual edification. Let's do what we do for the glory of God and the good of others.

PS: We will post again July 15.

Charismaticism Reconsidered--Preface

Why am I writing this? I write because this is a problem question that will not go away. As a believer, as a pastor, issues and questions related to the popular charismatic movement(s) resurface again and again.

These issues encompass everything from parents denying children medication because of their great faith in God's purported desire to work a miracle if they have enough faith to people getting a fresh word from God regarding His will for their lives or the lives of others. Then there are seemingly lesser issues ranging from the understanding of "tongues" to "modern miracle workers" who receive fresh revelations from God which seemingly contradict Scripture. Sometimes the matter seems benign; sometimes the matter is not so benign.

Complicating matters more is the diversity of the charismatic movement. There is no one single leader or theology. Thus, it is difficult to discuss charismaticism. One must instead generally address charismaticisms.

There are already many fine works on the topic. The question invariably arises, "Then why add to the body of work that already exists?" The answer is simply: Love. I do so out of love for God, His church invisible, and the local church which He has loaned me for a season.

Ultimately, I write this as a pastor to the people I love. It is certain others have covered the topic better than I (and in a more gracious, winsome, and capable way). Nevertheless, I am compelled to combine the many letters and questions I have answered over the course of several years for the good of and edification of the people I love at Bethel Baptist Church, in Green Bay, as well as those whom I have ministered to previously.

PS: I will post again on or before July 8th!